Grieving and Growing
Video Available: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=avDstG_FfCk
Grieving and Growing
Eicha's ordered acrostic structure sets limits on grief without denying it — mirroring the truth that loss does not shrink but new life grows around it, and we can be whole again, even if never the same.
The Sara Litton z"l Monthly Emunah Essay for Av:
The five chapters of Megilat Eicha feature multiple structural layers reflecting human complexity and conveying messages of hope amid destruction. Chapters 1-4 use alphabetic acrostics, with chapter 3 employing a triple acrostic, while chapter 5 echoes the Hebrew alphabet's 22 letters through non-alphabetical verses.
The "a to z" pattern evokes profound loss and suffering yet establishes limits to grief through ordered structure. Rabbi Sacks reflected that "Judaism is the voice of hope in the conversation of humankind," with "prophets, even the most pessimistic, were all agents of hope."
Chapters 1-2 feature chiastic symmetry where verse 1 parallels verse 22 and verse 2 parallels verse 21, creating an א"ת ב"ש pattern. This staircase-like structure, ascending and descending 11 steps, mirrors grief's cyclical nature—one step forward, two steps back—revisiting desolation repeatedly.
Yet this structure also resembles a circle. Lois Tonkin's "Growing Around Grief" model depicts loss as a black circle that doesn't shrink, while new life expands around it. Colors, experiences, growth, and joy encircle the dark pain. Dr. Kübler-Ross stated: "You will rebuild yourself around loss. You will be whole again but never the same."
Israeli artists created ceramic poppies (kalaniot) with dark centers honoring October 7th victims and brilliant red petals expressing hope for renewed life.
The book's chiastic structure presents five chapters as unified. Chapters 1 and 5 achieve "theological equilibrium," concluding God is just, while chapters 2 and 4 describe suffering without theological resolution.
Living with emunah doesn't mean avoiding questions or anger. The structure validates naturally occurring duality: outwardly maintaining simple faith while privately experiencing inner turmoil and rage—holding opposing emotions simultaneously.
The balance's secret lies in chapter 3's center: "This I shall place upon my heart, therefore I hope...They are renewed every morning, great is Your faithfulness...Hashem is my portion, my soul says, therefore I will hope in Him."
Daily gratitude through "modah ani" reinforces the phrase "רַבָּה אֱמוּנָתֶך" (great is Your faith), encouraging fullest living regardless of circumstances.
Holocaust survivor Edith Eger wrote that she survived "by drawing on my inner world…each of us has the capacity to gain perspective transforming us from victim to thriver."
Believing alef to tav that God remains present, we can heal, grieve, move forward and circle back, maintaining simple faith alongside inner resolve.
Related Articles
You might also be interested in these teachings
The Peacemaker's Paradox: Finding Wholeness in the Month of Av
The Temple fell to baseless hatred, yet God placed the yahrtzeit of Aharon — the great lover of peace — at the very threshold of Av, offering us both the wound and the remedy in the same breath.
Read MoreLove and Justice: Faithfulness Can Bring the Redemption
Faithfulness (ne'eman) bridges the six days between Tisha B'Av's mourning and Tu B'Av's joy, teaching us that when we build faithful homes we lay the groundwork for the city of justice and redemption the prophets envisioned.
Read MoreFighting Indifference
Esther acted without guarantees, entering the king's court before knowing how the story would end — and Taanit Esther teaches us to do the same: to fast, gather, and refuse indifference while we still stand inside the tension of waiting.
Read More